Skip to content
SMED and Changeover Reduction | Part 1 of 6

Why Changeover Time Decides Batch Size

Long changeovers force large batches, inventory and long lead times. The arithmetic of one press shows what shorter changeovers are worth.

Nobody in a plant likes large batches. Planners know they hide problems, logistics has to store them, and sales has to explain why the part the customer needs is scheduled for Thursday. Large batches exist anyway, because they are the answer to a long changeover.

The chain behind a large batch

A press needs 96 minutes to change from one part to the next. Every changeover costs running time, so planners avoid changeovers. Each part runs for a long time, the other parts wait for their turn, and the stock behind the machine has to cover the waiting. A quality problem or a customer change is found days later, in a full rack.

The changeover is the cause. Batch size, inventory and lead time are the effects.

The arithmetic of one press

Press P4 in a stamping plant runs 12 part numbers in two shifts with 900 planned minutes per day. It is changed over four times a day.

Item Value
Changeover time 96 minutes, last good part to first good part
Time lost per day 4 x 96 = 384 minutes, 43 percent of the planned time
Time lost per year 384 x 240 days / 60 = 1,536 hours
Interval of every part 12 parts / 4 changeovers = every third day
Average cycle stock Half a batch of three days = 1.5 days of demand

At a demand of EUR 36,000 per day at cost, 1.5 days of cycle stock tie up EUR 54,000 behind one press. An urgent order needs an extra changeover, which costs 96 minutes and EUR 240 at a machine hour rate of EUR 150. So it is refused or done on overtime.

What 29 minutes would change

Suppose the changeover takes 29 minutes. The plant now has a choice.

  • Same changeovers, more output: four changeovers cost 116 minutes instead of 384. That is 268 minutes more running time per day, 1,072 hours per year.
  • More changeovers, same output: twelve changeovers of 29 minutes cost 348 minutes, less than the four long ones today. Every part runs every day, and the average cycle stock falls to half a day of demand, EUR 18,000.
  • A mix: eight changeovers, 152 minutes more running time and half the batch size.

The rule for choosing is simple. If the machine is the bottleneck, take capacity first. If it is not, take smaller batches. More output from a machine that is not the bottleneck only builds inventory faster.

What SMED means

SMED stands for single minute exchange of die: a changeover in less than ten minutes, a single digit number. The method was developed in press shops and works on any machine that is converted from one product to another, such as injection molding machines, machining centers, packaging and filling lines.

It has a fixed order:

  1. Measure the changeover and break it into steps.
  2. Separate internal work, which needs the machine to stand, from external work, which does not.
  3. Convert internal work to external work.
  4. Streamline what remains.

The ten minutes are a direction. For most machines the first target is to halve what you have, and the first third usually costs nothing but attention.

Decide before you start

A shorter changeover changes nothing by itself. If the plan keeps the old batch sizes and the machine has no more orders, the minutes disappear. Before the first video is recorded, the production manager should say in one sentence what the gain is for: capacity, smaller batches or both. That sentence decides how the result will be measured, and it keeps the team motivated when the first improvements arrive.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.