Ask five people how long a changeover takes and you get five numbers. The setter counts from the first loosened bolt to the last tightened one. The planner counts what is in the system. The supervisor remembers the best one. Before anything can be improved, the plant needs one definition and real data.
One definition
Changeover time is the time from the last good part of the old job to the first good part of the new job at full speed.
It includes searching, fetching, waiting, trial parts, measuring and adjusting. It does not end when the tool is clamped. This definition is uncomfortable, because it makes the whole loss visible. That is its purpose.
Log every changeover
For two weeks, every changeover of the pilot machine is logged with two clock times: last good part and first good part. Minutes are calculated, not estimated. Above an agreed limit, the setter writes a reason on the same day.
On press P4, 20 changeovers in one week gave this picture:
| Measure | Value |
|---|---|
| Average | 96 minutes |
| Shortest | 78 minutes |
| Longest | 131 minutes |
| Most frequent reason | Waiting for forklift or crane, 7 of 20 |
The range of 53 minutes is the first finding. Same press, same team, same dies. The changeover has no standard, so its length depends on the day.
Record one changeover
The log shows how long. A video shows why. Film one normal changeover from the last good part to the first good part.
- Announce it. The team films the process, not the people, and the setters analyze the video themselves.
- Use a fixed camera position with the clock visible. A second person follows the setter and draws every walk on a layout sheet.
- A third person lists every tool, where it came from and whether it had to be searched for.
- Nobody helps and nobody comments. A normal changeover is the goal, not a record.
From video to step list
On the same or the next day the team watches the video and stops it at every change of activity. Each step gets one line: what happens, start, end, minutes. The sum must equal the changeover time.
Then each step is assigned to one of four groups. On P4 the 22 steps added up like this:
| Group | Minutes | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Preparation, fetching, transport, paperwork | 32.0 | 33 % |
| Removing and mounting | 32.5 | 34 % |
| Settings | 15.5 | 16 % |
| Trials and adjustments | 16.0 | 17 % |
The setter walked 410 meters. He waited eight minutes for a forklift and six minutes for the crane. The die itself was moved in eight minutes.
What to look for
Three things stand out in almost every first recording:
- Waiting and searching. They are faults of the organization, not of the setter. Mark them in color.
- Adjustments. Every second trial is a setting that was not right the first time.
- Work done alone. One person walks around a machine that two people could serve from two sides.
Ask the setter at every step what would make it easier. The ideas of the people who do the changeover are the ones that last, and most of them have been waiting for someone to ask.
The step list is now the map for everything that follows: the split into internal and external work, the levers and the standard.