Skip to content
Supplier Management | Part 2 of 10

Single, Dual or Multiple Sourcing

How many suppliers per part is a decision with a price. Choose the sourcing model per part family, and protect every single source.

After every supply crisis the same sentence appears in management meetings: “We need a second source for everything.” Six months later the second sources are expensive, half qualified and get too little volume to care.

The number of suppliers per part is a real decision with a real price. Make it deliberately, part family by part family.

Three sourcing models

Single source fits when tooling is expensive, volume is small or the supplier is a technology leader who developed the part with you. The price is dependency.

Dual source fits when volume is large, the part is critical for the line and the supply risk is high. The price is two approvals, two tools and less volume for each supplier.

Multiple source fits standard parts with many capable suppliers. The price is more administration and less partnership.

In the pump plant example, the main housing families are dual sourced with a split of 70 to 30. The motor is single sourced, because the supplier developed it together with the plant, and a second motor would mean a second design.

Make or buy first

Before choosing the number of suppliers, check whether the part should be bought at all. Four questions decide:

  1. Is it a core competence that sets your product apart?
  2. Do suppliers have better scale, technology or cost?
  3. Is your own capacity free and the investment justified?
  4. Would buying create a dependency you cannot manage?

A documented comparison of cost, capability, capacity and risk beats a decision based on the last budget meeting.

Single source is not the problem

Unmanaged single source is. A single source becomes acceptable when four things are in place:

  • a frame agreement that covers capacity and lead times,
  • a safety stock that matches the time to react,
  • ownership of the tools you paid for, with access if needed,
  • an exit plan: which supplier could take over, and how long it would take.

For the motor in the example, three weeks of safety stock and a capacity agreement cover the risk. The plan B is documented, even though nobody hopes to use it.

Dual sourcing needs volume

A second source with 5 percent of the volume is a supplier on paper. It will not keep its process stable, its people trained or its price competitive.

If dual sourcing is the decision, give the second source enough volume to stay capable, typically 20 to 40 percent. Measure both with the same scorecard and let the split move with performance.

Review the model yearly

Markets, volumes and technologies change. Review the sourcing model per category in the yearly strategy round, together with the segmentation. A decision made three years ago under different conditions is not a strategy, it is a habit.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.