The supplier has every certificate on the wall of the meeting room. In the foundry, the mold for your housing has not been maintained for 40,000 shots and the sampling plan does not look at the area where the porosity occurs.
Certificates show that a management system exists. A process audit shows whether your part is made right, every day.
Three kinds of audit
- System audit: organization, document control, training, improvement. For new suppliers and every few years.
- Process audit: the real process of your part or part family, from incoming material to shipping. Before series for critical parts and after major problems.
- Product audit: finished parts against drawing and specification, including packaging and labels. Regularly, on samples.
For supplier management, the process audit is the most useful. It is where you see the conditions that create next year’s complaints.
How to score it
Each question is scored 0, 4, 6, 8 or 10 points, and the result is the share of points reached:
- 90 percent or more: approved,
- 80 to 89 percent: approved with conditions and an action plan,
- below 80 percent: not approved.
One rule overrides the total. A question about product safety scored with 0 blocks the approval, whatever the percentage.
In the example, the casting supplier reached 73 percent: 74 in process planning, 62 in mold maintenance, 70 in inspection, 88 in handling and traceability. The result was no approval for new parts and a development plan for the existing ones.
Six questions that find most problems
- Show me the control plan, and where each control happens at the line.
- What happens to a part that fails the check?
- What triggers the next maintenance of this tool?
- Show me the capability study of the critical characteristic.
- Who may change a parameter, and where is it recorded?
- What was your last complaint, and what did you change?
Ask them at the station, not in the meeting room. The answer you get while standing next to the machine is usually the true one.
Audit with respect
An audit is not an inspection by a customer who wants to find faults. It is a structured look at a process that both sides want to work. Announce the scope, bring an auditor who knows the process, and share the findings on the same day.
Good suppliers use the audit to get support for investments their own management has postponed. A clear finding on mold maintenance can be the argument they needed.
Close the loop
Every finding becomes an action with owner and date. Findings that affect product quality are checked again on site, not by email. Repeat the audit after major problems, after a move of production and at least every three years for critical parts.