Skip to content
Supplier Management | Part 7 of 10

Supplier Complaints Close at the Root Cause

Containment in 24 hours, a verified cause in 10 days, proven effectiveness in 60: how to run 8D with suppliers and rate the reports.

The complaint went out, the credit note came back, the case was closed. Four months later the same porosity appears in the same housing.

A supplier complaint is closed when the cause is removed and the effect is proven. Everything else is bookkeeping.

Four deadlines

The 8D method gives a complaint a structure. Fixed deadlines give it a pace:

  • 24 hours, D1 to D3: team named, problem described with facts, containment at the supplier, in transit and in your stock, with quantities.
  • 10 working days, D4: root cause found and verified.
  • 30 working days, D5 and D6: permanent actions chosen and implemented.
  • 60 working days, D7 and D8: effectiveness proven with data, standards changed, team closed.

Track every complaint against these dates in one list. Overdue steps are the agenda of the weekly complaint review.

Two causes, always

Every defect that reaches you has two causes: why it was made, and why it left the supplier.

In the casting example, the cause of occurrence was a worn mold section that produced porosity at the sealing surface. The cause of escape was a sampling plan that did not inspect that area. Fixing only the first leaves the door open for the next defect. Fixing only the second turns a supplier problem into a sorting operation.

Rate the quality of the 8D

Five questions show whether a report is worth accepting:

  1. Is the problem described with facts: part, characteristic, quantity, batch, date?
  2. Is containment complete, with numbers for every location?
  3. Are both causes found and verified, for example by switching them on and off?
  4. Do the actions act on the causes, through error proofing or a process change?
  5. Is effectiveness proven with the same measure as the problem?

“Root cause: operator error. Action: retraining.” fails questions 3 and 4. Ask which condition made the error possible and how it will be prevented or detected. Send the report back with that question.

Feed it into the scorecard

The quality of 8D reports is part of the collaboration rating. In the example, the casting supplier answered four complaints in a row with retraining as the main action, which is one reason for its collaboration score of 60 out of 100.

Look at your own share

Some complaints start at home: an unclear drawing, a changed specification nobody told the supplier about, damage in your own handling. Check these before the complaint goes out. A supplier who receives fair complaints takes them seriously.

Close with data

Close a complaint when the measure that showed the problem shows it is gone, over an agreed period, typically 30 days or three deliveries. Then ask one more question: where else can this happen, at this supplier and at others?

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.