Skip to content
Supplier Management | Part 6 of 10

One Scorecard for Every Key Supplier

Quality, delivery, cost and collaboration with fixed weights and point rules, measured monthly and shared with the suppliers.

Ask purchasing, quality and logistics which supplier is the worst and you get three different names. Each department judges by what hurts it most. The supplier hears three different messages and fixes none of them.

A scorecard replaces three opinions with one set of rules.

Four criteria, fixed weights

  • Quality, 40 percent: rejected parts per million delivered parts.
  • Delivery, 30 percent: on-time in-full, the share of order lines delivered on time and complete.
  • Cost, 15 percent: price development, cost ideas, invoice quality, rated 0 to 100 by purchasing.
  • Collaboration, 15 percent: response time, quality of 8D reports, openness, rated 0 to 100 by quality and logistics.

Quality and delivery come from your systems. The ratings come from people, with one sentence of reason each.

Point rules everyone knows

Measured values are turned into points with simple bands:

  • quality: 150 ppm or less is 100 points, up to 500 is 70, up to 1,000 is 40, above is 0,
  • delivery: 98 percent or more is 100 points, from 95 is 80, from 90 is 50, below is 0.

The total is the weighted sum. 80 or more is class A, 60 to 79 class B, below 60 class C.

A worked example

A casting supplier in March: 820 ppm gives 40 points, 88 percent on-time in-full gives 0 points, cost is rated 70 and collaboration 60. The total is 0.4 × 40 + 0.3 × 0 + 0.15 × 70 + 0.15 × 60 = 35.5. Class C.

This is not a reason to switch the supplier tomorrow. A new casting source needs a tool and six months of approval. It is a reason to start a development plan now.

Share it with the suppliers

A target the supplier does not know is not a target. Send the rules once, and the results every month. Most suppliers react to a clear number faster than to any complaint letter.

Measure fairly

If your own forecast changed three times in the month, the late delivery may be your problem. Record schedule changes you caused next to the delivery score. In the example, half of the late deliveries started with a schedule change of less than one week by the plant. A frozen schedule of two weeks fixed more than any escalation could.

Use it every month

The scorecard lives in a monthly supplier performance meeting of 60 minutes with purchasing, quality and logistics. Class C suppliers enter a defined escalation path:

  1. Class C in one month: letter with data, action plan within 10 working days.
  2. Class C for three months: management meeting, development plan, new business on hold.
  3. No improvement after six months: second source or phase out with a transition plan.

Start with the 20 to 45 suppliers that carry most of the value. Scoring all suppliers creates work, not improvement.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.