Skip to content
Supplier Management | Part 9 of 10

Total Cost of Ownership Beats Unit Price

Freight, customs handling, inventory, quality and support turn a large price advantage into a small one. A worked comparison and a should-cost model.

A distant foundry offers a housing casting for EUR 18.40. The regional source charges EUR 21.10. With 60,000 parts a year, the difference looks like EUR 162,000 of savings.

The unit price is the visible part of the cost. Total cost of ownership adds the rest.

A worked comparison

Cost per part in EUR:

Element Distant Regional
Unit price 18.40 21.10
Freight and handling 1.10 0.25
Customs handling and duties 0.60 0.00
Inventory carrying, 8 weeks more stock 0.45 0.10
Quality cost: inspection, scrap, complaints 0.55 0.15
Travel, audits, supplier support 0.20 0.05
Total cost of ownership 21.30 21.65

The real difference is EUR 0.35 per part, or EUR 21,000 a year. About 13 percent of the apparent saving remains, and that is before the risk of a longer and more fragile supply chain.

Where the hidden cost sits

  • Freight and handling: transport, packaging, customs agents, internal handling of larger lots.
  • Inventory carrying: longer transport means more stock in transit and in your warehouse. Capital, space and the risk of obsolete parts cost money.
  • Quality cost: incoming inspection, sorting, scrap and complaint handling, often higher in the first years with a new source.
  • Support: travel for audits, launches and problem solving.
  • Tooling and approval: a second tool and the cost of a full part approval.

None of these appear in the quotation. All of them appear in your plant.

Use it in every decision

Make the total cost comparison part of every sourcing decision above a threshold, for example EUR 250,000 of annual volume. In the selection matrix, total cost replaces price as the cost criterion.

Lower cost with a should-cost model

Total cost tells you which offer is cheaper. A should-cost model tells you what a part should cost. For the casting: material for 11.5 kg of iron EUR 8.90, melting energy 2.10, molding and cores 2.70, cleaning and inspection 1.50, overhead 1.60, scrap allowance 0.80, margin 2.00. Total EUR 19.60.

The regional quote of EUR 21.10 is EUR 1.50 above the model. That gap is the agenda of the negotiation, element by element. In the example, the supplier had calculated molding with an older machine. A joint project on setup and cycle time closed EUR 0.90 of the gap, shared equally between both sides.

Other levers

Specification reviews remove tolerances and surfaces that cost money without function. Bundling volume and longer agreements give suppliers planning security. Indexing raw material and energy prices to public indexes ends the yearly fight over the same arguments.

Cost work with suppliers is most effective when it reduces the cost of making the part, not only the margin on it.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.