Many plants have a value stream map on a wall. Far fewer have a stream that changed because of it. The difference is whether the future state became a plan with owners and dates, and whether somebody reviewed it every month.
The plan on one page
The value stream plan answers four questions for each loop: what exactly will be different, how will we measure it, who owns it and by when.
| Loop | Goal you can measure | Owner |
|---|---|---|
| 1 Pacemaker | Cell in flow with two operators, changeover 15 minutes, finished goods at most 1.8 days | Supervisor machining |
| 2 Casting | Casting interval two days, trimmed castings at most 2.5 days, leak test 98.5 percent | Supervisor casting |
| 3 Supplier | Two ingot deliveries per week, raw material at most 3.25 days | Logistics |
Each goal is a state of the stream that can be checked by walking to it. “Introduce kanban” is an activity. “Finished goods at most 1.8 days” is a goal.
Only the first loop is planned in detail. For the housing stream that meant eight actions in twelve weeks, from moving the leak test and assembly next to machining to stopping the weekly schedules. The later loops get their action lists when their turn comes.
The business case
A plan needs resources, and resources need a case.
| Item | EUR per year |
|---|---|
| Carrying cost of less inventory | 23,730 |
| Less scrap | 66,000 |
| No premium freight | 21,600 |
| Benefit per year | 111,330 |
The inventory falls in value from EUR 165,150 to EUR 46,500, and the better yield saves about 3,000 housings a year. Against that stands a one-time cost of EUR 60,000. Payback takes about six and a half months. The largest effect is not in the table: on-time delivery of 98 percent instead of 91.
The review
The plan is reviewed where the stream is, at the two maps on the wall.
- Weekly: the value stream manager and the loop owner walk the loop and look at the actions of the week.
- Monthly: value stream manager, plant manager and loop owners go through the plan. Each goal is on track, behind or done. Then lead time, delivery and yield.
- Quarterly: plant management decides whether a loop is closed and the next one starts.
A loop is closed with a recount of the inventory, not with a status report. The lead time is what the count says.
Nine months in the example
| Month | What happened | Lead time |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | Current state mapped | 16.5 days |
| 3 | Cell running, leveling box in use | 11.6 days |
| 6 | Trim at the casting cell, casting every two days | 8.1 days |
| 9 | Ingots twice a week | 5.3 days |
The plan said 11.5, 8.0 and 5.0 days. The stream came close, and not everything went to plan. Casting uptime reached 88 percent instead of 90. Some ingot loads still arrive early, which is why 0.3 days more than designed sit in raw material. Both items are the first lines of the next plan.
Signs that it works
- The daily shortage meeting was canceled, because there is nothing left to chase.
- Operators stop when a FIFO lane is full, and nobody tells them to keep busy.
- A missed pitch is discussed within the hour.
- The map on the wall carries handwritten changes.
The next map
When the future state is reached, it becomes the current state. The team walks the stream again, counts again and draws again. After the first cycle the plant has people who see the flow from door to door, numbers they agreed on, and the habit of asking what the stream needs next.