Skip to content
Value Stream Mapping | Part 5 of 8

Lead Time Ladder and Flow Efficiency: Two Totals, One Ratio

How to build the lead time ladder under a value stream map, calculate flow efficiency and read where the days are.

Along the bottom of every value stream map runs a stepped line. On the upper steps stands the time material waits, on the lower steps the time it is worked on. This lead time ladder turns the whole map into two totals and one ratio.

Building the ladder

Take each inventory in days and each process with its processing time, in the order of the flow.

Waiting Days Process Seconds
Alloy ingots 5.0 Die casting 55
Castings 3.0 Trim and deburr 40
Trimmed castings 2.0 CNC machining 200
Machined housings 1.5 Wash and leak test 50
Tested housings 1.0 Assembly and pack 105
Finished housings 4.0 Shipping

The upper steps add up to the lead time: 16.5 days. The lower steps add up to the value-added time: 450 seconds, or 7.5 minutes.

Three conventions

Three choices have to be made the same way every time.

Processing time is per piece. Machining runs two machines in parallel. A housing leaves every 100 seconds, but each housing spends 200 seconds in a machine. The ladder takes the 200.

Inventory days use customer demand. Pieces divided by 450, at every point. Raw material is converted into piece equivalents first.

Days are working days. One day is the available time of the stream, here 54,000 seconds in two shifts.

Flow efficiency

Flow efficiency is the share of the lead time in which value is added.

Flow efficiency = value-added time / lead time = 450 / (16.5 x 54,000 + 450) = 0.05 percent.

Put differently: for each minute a housing is worked on, it waits 1,980 minutes, which is 33 working hours.

A flow efficiency well below one percent is the normal result of processes that were optimized one by one. The value of the number is that it moves when the stream improves and stays flat when only a process does.

Two more numbers from the same data

Inventory turns of the stream. Working days per year divided by the lead time: 240 / 16.5 = 14.5 turns.

Rolled first pass yield. Multiply the first pass yields along the stream: 0.96 x 0.99 x 0.98 x 0.97 = 90.3 percent. Of 100 castings poured, 90 leave as good housings.

Reading the ladder

Start with the largest steps.

Five days of ingots. The supplier delivers once a week, so the stock swings between a full week and nearly nothing.

Four days of finished goods. The customer calls off every day with one day of notice. The plant needs sixteen days to respond, so it protects itself with stock. It still delivers only 91 percent on time, because the stock is often the wrong variant.

Three and two days in the middle. Castings wait because die casting runs each variant once in five days. Trimmed castings wait because machining runs the smaller variant every second day.

Then look at where quality is lost. The leak test fails 3 percent of the housings. The cause is porosity from die casting, but the test stands three processes downstream. Between the pour and the test lie 6.5 days of inventory. By the time a leak is found, 200 seconds of machining were spent on a part that was scrap from the start.

What the ladder does not say

The ladder does not tell you to cut inventory. Inventory is a result. Take the finished goods away tomorrow and delivery gets worse.

It tells you where to ask why. The answers are changeover times, free capacity, distances and the way information travels. The future state changes those, and the inventory follows.

A first target

A current state map should not leave the room without a target. The housing team agreed on 8.0 days within six months. From that day the stream had what the departments never had together: one number, an owner and a date.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.