A plant rarely has too few work instructions. It has too many of the wrong ones. There is a six-page document on how to fold cartons, and nothing on how to change the saw blade. The reason is simple: documents were written when an audit asked for them, not when a task needed them.
The way out starts with the tasks, not with the documents.
Take stock first
The example in this series is the cylinder assembly and test area of a plant for pneumatic cylinders: six stations, 24 operators, two shifts. In one week the supervisor and the team leaders made three lists.
- The tasks. Every piece of work with a start and an end that one person can be trained on. The area has 60.
- The documents on file. 38 instructions, text only, five pages on average. For 21 of them the review was overdue.
- The copies at the stations. 46 printed sheets in holders, drawers and folders. 13 of them were outdated, and four handwritten notes could not be assigned to any document.
The 13 outdated copies were replaced on the same day. One poor version at the station is better than two.
Three ratings
Not every task needs a document. Three ratings from 1 to 3 decide.
| Rating | 1 | 2 | 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Risk | Error is fixed at once | Rework, scrap, late order | Injury, complaint, safety function |
| Frequency | Less than weekly | Daily to weekly | Many times per shift |
| Change | Same people, one variant | Rotation or variants | New people often, long gaps |
The score is risk times frequency times change, from 1 to 27. One rule stands above the score: a task with risk 3 always gets a full instruction. Changing the saw blade is done once a month and scores only 6, but an error can injure.
The sources for the risk rating are the risk assessment of the workplace, the process FMEA and the control plan where they exist, complaints and the defect records of the last twelve months. The supervisor, a team leader, the quality engineer and the safety officer rate together. One minute per task is enough. Discussion is only needed where two people differ by two points.
Three classes
| Class | Rule | What the task gets | Tasks |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | Risk 3, or score 12 and above | Full visual instruction, tried out, trained, checked | 14 |
| B | Score 6 to 9 | Short instruction: one picture, one point, one reason | 22 |
| C | Score 4 and below | No document, shown during training | 24 |
The list turned 38 old documents and 22 gaps into a plan. Of the 14 class A tasks, nine had a document that had to be rewritten and five had none at all. Of the 22 class B tasks, sixteen documents were cut down to half a page and six were written new. Thirteen documents belonged to class C tasks and were withdrawn without replacement.
The area ends up with 36 instructions instead of 38, and each one has a reason to exist.
Withdrawing is a decision
Removing a document feels risky. Somebody once asked for it. But every document that hangs at a station without a purpose teaches operators that sheets can be ignored. Fewer documents mean that the remaining ones are read, reviewed and kept current. The withdrawal is decided by the area manager, listed with a date and kept in the register, so that an auditor can see it was a choice and not a loss.
Where to start
Start with the highest score. In the example this is the assembly of the 63 mm cylinder at station A3 with 27 points: a leak reaches the customer, the task is done 300 times a day and nine operators rotate through the station. It also has a result figure directly behind it. The leak test fails 4.2 percent of the cylinders, which means 252 reworks per month.
A task with numbers and a willing team is the right pilot. The next part shows what its instruction looks like.