One product, one instruction is easy. Then the product comes in three sizes, with two options and in a version for export. If every combination gets its own copy of the instruction, the area soon has more documents than anyone can keep current, and each change must be made in six places.
Variants multiply documents. The answer is to write down only what differs.
Four situations
| Situation | Solution |
|---|---|
| Same steps, different values | One instruction with a variant table |
| Same steps plus a few extra ones | Base instruction plus an add-on sheet |
| Different steps or tools | A separate instruction |
| Options chosen per order | The order paper names the add-on sheets |
The assembly area of the example plant builds cylinders with 63, 80 and 100 mm bore. The 63 mm cylinder has its own instruction, because fitting cone, insertion sleeve and fixture differ from the larger ones. The 80 and 100 mm cylinders share one sheet. The steps are identical and only four values change.
The variant table
| Bore | Cone and sleeve | Grease | Tie rod torque |
|---|---|---|---|
| 63 mm | Set 63, blue | 2 g, one stroke | 12 Nm |
| 80 mm | Set 80, green | 3 g, one stroke | 25 Nm |
| 100 mm | Set 100, yellow | 4 g, two strokes | 25 Nm |
The color of the tool set is repeated on the sheet and on the tray of the seal kit.
The table follows one rule: one value, one place. A torque that appears in three instructions will be wrong in one of them after the next change. Shared values live in one table, and the register names their source, which is the drawing or the control plan.
The add-on sheet
Cylinders with adjustable cushioning need two extra steps: fitting the cushioning seal and setting the adjustment screw to its basic position. These two steps are on an add-on sheet with their own key points, reasons and photos. The base instruction stays untouched. The add-on sheet has its own identifier and version and names the base instruction it belongs to.
For products that are configured per order, such as valve units with four to eight valves, the order paper lists which add-on sheets apply.
Setup instructions
Setup tasks are a special case. They are done rarely compared with the production task, often under time pressure, and an error affects the whole batch that follows. In the rating of tasks they often reach class A or B through their risk.
A setup instruction has four parts.
- Before the stop. What is brought to the station while the last job still runs. For the bore change at A3: tool set and seal kits of the next bore and the torque tool for 25 Nm.
- Sequence. Five to ten steps with key points and reasons, as in any instruction. The bore change has five steps and takes four minutes.
- Settings table. Every value per variant in one table, with its source. This is the variant table above.
- First part check. What is checked on the first part, by whom, and where it is signed. At A3 the first cylinder of the new bore is leak tested and signed on the order paper before the batch continues.
The first part check is the part most often missing. Without it, a wrong setting is found at the end of the batch or by the customer.
When a variant needs its own instruction
If more than a third of the steps differ, or if other tools are used, write a separate instruction. A variant table with ten columns and footnotes is harder to read than two clean sheets. If only values differ, never copy the instruction.
Keeping it together
Variant tables and add-on sheets are controlled documents like any other. They are listed in the register, have a version and an owner and are checked after every engineering change. The settings table gets one extra rule: after a change of a drawing or a control plan, the owner compares every value in the table with its source and signs the comparison.