Skip to content
Work Instructions | Part 3 of 6

Writing Work Instructions With Operators and Testing Them at the Station

The job breakdown in five passes, the roles of author, operators and quality, and a tryout that turns every hesitation into a finding.

Most instructions are written at a desk by someone who knows the product, checked by someone who knows the standard and released to people who know the job better than both. The result describes how the work was planned, not how it is done.

A better instruction is written at the station, and it is tested there before anyone signs it.

Who writes

The author holds the pen. The content comes from the station.

  • Author: a team leader or trainer. Watches, asks, writes, takes the photos.
  • Operators: two who do the job, from different shifts. They show the job and name the key points.
  • Quality engineer: brings the defect records and confirms values and reasons.
  • Safety officer: checks the safety key points against the risk assessment.
  • Owner: the supervisor. Approves, provides time and decides in case of doubt.

The job breakdown in five passes

  1. Watch the job three times without writing. Agree where the task starts and where it ends.
  2. Write the steps and read them back to the operator while the job is done.
  3. Go through the steps again with three questions: what can injure, what makes a defect, what makes it easier?
  4. Ask for the reason of every key point. Remove key points for which nobody finds a reason.
  5. Compare both shifts. Where they differ, decide on one method before it is written down.

At station A3 of the example plant, the breakdown of the 63 mm cylinder assembly produced four findings before a single line was written. The early shift greased the tube, the late shift only the seal. The fitting cone was used by three of nine operators. The old text asked for 15 Nm on the tie rods, the drawing for 12 Nm. And the leak test time was shortened by hand whenever the line was behind.

None of this was in the old document.

The tryout

A draft is a guess about what readers will understand. The tryout replaces the guess with an observation.

Three operators who did not write the instruction do the job from the draft alone: one experienced, one from the other shift, one new. They work at the real station with real parts. The author watches and stays silent, because every explanation hides a fault of the sheet. Every hesitation, every question and every wrong move is written down as a finding. The tester is never wrong. The sheet is.

Type of finding Draft 1 Draft 2 Draft 3
Wording unclear 4 1 0
Picture unclear or missing 2 1 0
Key point missing 2 0 0
Order of steps wrong 1 0 0
Total 9 2 0

The most valuable tester was the new operator. She twisted the piston while pushing it into the tube, and she put the finished cylinder on the tray without protective caps. Both were key points that the experienced people no longer saw. The first draft had ten key points, the released version has twelve.

Release criteria

An instruction is ready for approval when four things are true.

  • No finding is open on a key point, a value or the order of steps.
  • An operator names the key point of any step within ten seconds from one meter.
  • The new operator completed the job with the sheet and one demonstration, and the part passed the normal check.
  • The quality engineer has confirmed every value against the drawing, the control plan or the machine data.

What it costs

The tryout at A3 took an hour and a half in total, spread over three days. Draft 1 was tested on Monday, draft 3 was approved on Thursday. A complete class A instruction takes about six hours: two at the station, one and a half for photos and the sheet, one and a half for the tryout and one for approval and training material.

Six hours is more than copying the old text into a new template. It is far less than the 252 reworks per month that the old text did not prevent.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.