Skip to content
Work Measurement and Capacity | Part 3 of 8

Performance Rating and Allowances in Plain Words

How rating turns an observed time into a basic time, how rest and delay allowances are built, and how to state the uncertainty honestly.

The observed time belongs to the person who was observed on that day. The standard time has to work for any trained person on any day. Two steps bridge that gap, and one of them is a judgment.

What rating is

Rating means comparing the pace you see with a reference pace the plant has written down and filmed. The reference is 100. A slower pace is rated below 100, a faster one above it. The basic time is the observed time times the rating divided by 100.

At station S3 the operator was rated at 95, so 150.4 observed seconds became 142.9 basic seconds. The number went down because the pace seen was slightly below the reference, and the standard time has to describe the reference, not the day.

Make the judgment comparable

Rating cannot be made objective, but it can be made comparable.

Write the reference down: one page describing the pace a trained person holds through a full shift, plus two filmed reference cycles. Train with film: four recorded cycles rated independently, then compared and discussed in writing. Agree a band: two trained observers must land within five points of each other on the same filmed cycle, and a study outside the band is repeated rather than argued about. Rate per element when the cycle mixes a slow and a fast part, because one rating for a mixed cycle hides the slow one. And let two people rate the times that carry a quotation or an investment.

Say the uncertainty out loud

Rating adds an uncertainty that no number of cycles removes. State it. The standard time of S3 is 2.83 minutes at a rating of 95 with an observer band of five points, which is roughly plus or minus 0.14 minutes. A reader who knows that will use the time correctly. A reader handed a bare 2.83 will not.

Rating has no place in machine-paced work, where the time is read from the equipment, and none in work that is mostly waiting, where sampling gives the shares of the day instead.

Allowances make the time holdable

Allowances are the part of the standard time that makes it possible to work at the rated pace for a whole shift. Two of them are enough for most plants.

The rest allowance covers recovery from force, posture, repetition, attention and the environment. The personal and delay allowance covers personal needs and short unavoidable interruptions. In area M2 they were set at 8 and 5 percent, applied to the manual work only. Those are freely chosen example values; your own table is built from your own conditions, documented, and approved once for the plant rather than negotiated at every study.

Four rules keep allowances honest. One table for the whole plant, because different allowances for the same conditions in two areas invite negotiation. Never a place to park losses: searching for parts and waiting for a crane belong on the improvement list. Never on machine running time, because a test cycle of 2.65 minutes needs no recovery while the 0.56 minutes of loading does. And reviewed whenever a lifting aid, a layout or a material changes.

The setup share, and why the lot size belongs in the record

The last piece is the setup time spread over the planning lot. At S3, 35 minutes per lot of 250 units gives 0.14 minutes per unit.

Step S3 value
Observed time, fourteen cycles 150.4 s
Rating 95, so basic time 142.9 s
Plus 13 percent allowance 161.5 s
In minutes 2.69 min
Plus setup share 0.14 min
Standard time per unit 2.83 min

A setup share is only valid for the lot it was calculated with. Halve the lot and the standard time of S3 rises to 2.97 minutes. Record the setup time and the lot size separately, and the share can be recalculated instead of re-measured when planning changes the lot.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.