Skip to content
Factory Layout Planning | Part 2 of 8

The From-To Matrix: Transport Intensity and Transport Effort

How to count transports between areas, build a from-to matrix and calculate the transport effort of a layout in meters per day.

A layout decides how far material travels. To judge it, you need to know what travels: how many transports per day go from which area to which other area. The from-to matrix holds exactly this, and one multiplication turns it into the number every layout variant has to beat.

Count transports, not pieces

The unit of the matrix is the transport: one trip of a forklift, a pallet truck or a cart with one load unit. One pallet with four housings is one trip, whether it carries four housings or forty covers.

There are three sources for the numbers:

  • Routings and load units. Quantity per day divided by pieces per load unit gives the loads per day on every leg of a routing. Fast, but blind to detours.
  • Transport orders or scans. One to four weeks of booked moves show the real flow, if every move is booked.
  • A count. One shift at three aisle crossings checks both. Differences above a fifth need an explanation.

Add what the routings do not show: purchased parts, rework, empties that travel alone.

The flows of the pump plant

The hall of the example has ten areas. Between them, 14 flows carry 260 transports per day. The strongest are:

From To What Per day
Machining centers Washing Housings and covers 33
Receiving Machining centers Cast housings 25
Washing Painting Housings 25
Painting Assembly Painted housings 25
Assembly Testing Pump units 25
Testing Shipping Tested units 25

In the matrix, every flow stands in the row of its source and the column of its target. Entries close to the diagonal mean that the order of the areas in the list matches the flow. Entries below the diagonal are backflows. The pump plant has one: rework from testing to assembly, 2 per day.

From intensity to effort

Transport intensity says how much flows. Transport effort says what the layout makes of it:

Transport effort = transports per day x distance, added over all flows.

For a block layout, distance is measured between the centers of two areas along the directions of the aisles: the east-west distance plus the north-south distance. In the hall of today, receiving has its center 10 m east and 10 m south of the northwest corner, the machining centers 60 m east and 50 m south. The distance is 50 + 40 = 90 meters, and 25 pallets of housings per day make 2,250 meters.

The rule is simple, and it is the same for every variant. That matters more than the last meter of accuracy.

What today costs

Flow Per day Meters Meters per day
Testing to shipping 25 95 2,375
Receiving to machining centers 25 90 2,250
Machining centers to washing 33 55 1,815
Assembly to testing 25 70 1,750
Washing to assembly 18 80 1,440

These five of the 14 flows add up to 9,630 meters. All flows together make 14,100 meters per day, 54 meters per transport. Five flows carry 68 percent of the effort, and a better layout starts with them.

Meters, hours, euros

Loaded meters are half of the story, because the truck drives back. With an empty return the hall sees 28,200 meters per day. At 80 meters per minute that is 352.5 minutes, almost 6 hours of pure travel per day, 1,410 hours per year. At EUR 50 per forklift hour, travel alone costs EUR 70,500 per year.

The number that counts for the project is 14,100. Every pump unit carries 141 meters of loaded transport through the hall before it leaves. The next step asks which areas should stand together, for reasons of flow and for other reasons.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.