Material flow is the strongest reason to put two areas side by side. It is not the only one. Two areas may share a team, a utility or a measuring room. And some areas should not be neighbors at all. The relationship rating collects all of this in one sheet, and the relationship diagram turns it into a first picture of the layout.
A scale with six steps
Classic layout methods use a letter scale for closeness. Any scale works as long as it is defined before the rating starts. The pump plant of this series uses numbers:
| Meaning | Rule | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Essential | 25 or more transports per day, or a technical must | 4 |
| Important | 15 to 24 transports per day | 3 |
| Useful | 8 to 14 transports per day | 2 |
| Minor | 1 to 7 transports per day | 1 |
| None | No flow and no other reason | 0 |
| Keep apart | Dust, vibration, noise, heat or hazard | X |
The limits come from the from-to matrix of the hall. Set them so that the top class holds a handful of pairs, not half of them.
Flow ratings are not negotiable
Ten areas form 45 possible pairs. In the pump plant, 13 of them exchange material. The transports in both directions give the flow rating, and six pairs reach a 4:
| Pair | Transports per day |
|---|---|
| Machining centers and washing | 33 |
| Assembly and testing | 27 |
| Receiving and machining centers | 25 |
| Washing and painting | 25 |
| Painting and assembly | 25 |
| Testing and shipping | 25 |
These six pairs form one chain from receiving to shipping, the route of the housing.
Reasons that are not flow
- Shared people. Receiving and shipping exchange no material, but they share the dock crew and the forklifts. Rating 2.
- Shared services. Turning and the machining centers use the same tool presetting and coolant service. Their flow of 8 transports per day gives a 2, and the shared service lifts it to a 3.
- Disturbance. Grinding produces dust and vibration, and the test benches measure pressure and flow rate. The pair gets an X.
- Fast feedback. Testing and assembly belong together, because rework should go back within minutes.
One rule keeps the sheet honest. Every rating above the flow value needs a written reason. Without it, every department head declares every neighbor essential, and the rating says nothing.
The other reasons are rated in one session with production, logistics, maintenance, quality and safety.
The diagram
Draw each area as a box of the same size on an empty sheet. Connect the pairs rated 4 with four lines, the pairs rated 3 with three lines, and so on. Mark keep-apart pairs in a different color. Then move the boxes until the thick connections are short and do not cross.
The diagram has no scale and no walls. It is the starting point of the ideal layout.
The check against today
The rating sheet gets one more column: does the pair share a border in the layout of today?
In the pump plant the answer is sobering. None of the six pairs rated 4 shares a border. The machining centers stand in the southeast corner, 90 meters from receiving and 55 meters from washing. Testing sits in the northeast, where the old tool room was, 95 meters from shipping. And the one pair rated X, grinding and testing, stands side by side.
Of the four pairs rated 3, two share a border: receiving and sawing, sawing and turning.
Three numbers summarize the layout of today: 0 of 6 essential pairs together, 2 of 4 important pairs together, 1 keep-apart pair together. Any new layout can be checked with the same three numbers in a few minutes, before a single distance is calculated.