Whoever starts a layout on the plan of the existing hall moves what is easy to move. Layout planning therefore takes two steps. First the ideal layout, which follows the flow alone. Then the real layout, in which the building has its say and every restriction gets a price.
The ideal layout
The ideal layout is built from the relationship rating and the space balance, on an empty grid:
- Place the two areas of the strongest pair side by side.
- Add the area with the strongest connection to those already placed.
- Keep the main flow in one direction: a line, a U or an L.
- Give every area its required size in a compact shape.
- Calculate the transport effort. This is the benchmark.
In the pump plant of this series the chain of the housing sets the shape: receiving, machining centers, washing, painting, assembly, testing, shipping. Receiving and shipping share one wall and one dock crew, so the flow has to return. The result is a U.
Basic flow shapes
- Straight line. Receiving and shipping on opposite walls. Shortest flow, but empties and trucks travel the full length back.
- U. Receiving and shipping on the same wall. The turn needs space, and the first and last area compete for the dock side.
- Comb or spine. Several lines feed one assembly along a main aisle that must stay free of storage.
The pump plant as a U
Material enters in the northwest. The north band holds receiving, sawing, turning and grinding from west to east. The middle band holds the machining centers next to receiving, then washing and painting. The south band runs back west: assembly, testing, shipping.
| Measure | Today | Ideal |
|---|---|---|
| Transport effort, meters per day | 14,100 | 7,250 |
| Average distance per transport, meters | 54 | 28 |
| Essential pairs that share a border, of 6 | 0 | 6 |
The ideal layout cuts the transport effort by 49 percent. It ignores one thing: in this layout painting stands 10 m further west than the paint shop of today.
What the building says
Now the restrictions come back, one by one:
- The paint shop. Moving it would cost EUR 420,000 and three weeks without painting. It stays where it is.
- The docks. Both on the west wall. This was already part of the ideal layout.
- The drain channel. It runs along the middle band, so washing stays there.
With the paint shop in its old position, washing no longer fits beside it in the same shape. It turns by 90 degrees and lies across two cells, and the reserve moves from the east wall to the cells south of washing.
The real layout
The real layout that results is called variant B in the project. Its transport effort is 7,980 meters per day, 43 percent below today. All six essential pairs still share a border.
The gap to the ideal layout is 730 meters per day. That is the price of leaving the paint shop where it is, in a currency that can be compared with the EUR 420,000 the move would cost.
Show what got worse
Every layout makes some flows longer. In variant B there are two:
| Flow | Per day | Meters today | Meters in B |
|---|---|---|---|
| Receiving to assembly, purchased parts | 14 | 35 | 85 |
| Grinding to washing, shafts | 10 | 22 | 35 |
Receiving and assembly sit at the two ends of the U, and grinding moved east to get away from the test benches. Together the two flows cost about 830 meters per day more. The other twelve flows save about 6,950.
Name the losers before somebody else finds them, and show the total. A layout that hides its weak points loses trust at the first walk through the hall.