One layout proposal is an opinion. Three proposals with the same numbers are a decision. The evaluation has three views: transport effort, a utility analysis and money.
Three variants
The pump plant of this series compares three ways to change its hall of 4,800 square meters:
| Variant | What changes | Meters per day | Investment in EUR |
|---|---|---|---|
| A Minimal | Only testing moves next to shipping | 11,270 | 50,000 |
| B U-flow | All areas move except receiving, painting, shipping | 7,980 | 310,000 |
| C Ideal | As B, and the paint shop moves 10 m west | 7,250 | 730,000 |
Today the hall has 14,100 meters per day. Variant A cuts that by 20 percent, B by 43 percent, C by 49 percent.
Variant A has a flaw: assembly stays at 800 square meters, so the extension would still be needed.
The utility analysis
A utility analysis scores each variant against weighted criteria. Six criteria with weights that add up to 100, scores from 1 to 5:
| Criterion | Weight | A | B | C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Material flow | 30 | 2 | 4 | 5 |
| Space for assembly and reserve | 20 | 1 | 5 | 5 |
| Flexibility and expansion | 15 | 2 | 4 | 4 |
| Safety and work environment | 15 | 3 | 4 | 4 |
| Implementation risk and downtime | 10 | 5 | 3 | 1 |
| Transparency and supervision | 10 | 2 | 4 | 4 |
| Weighted score out of 500 | 100 | 225 | 410 | 420 |
Variant B: 30 x 4 + 20 x 5 + 15 x 4 + 15 x 4 + 10 x 3 + 10 x 4 = 410. The layout of today scores 180.
Rules for an honest score
- Weights first. Criteria and weights are agreed before the variants are shown.
- No money inside. Investment and savings are compared separately.
- Score by rule. Where a number exists, the number sets the score. For material flow: above 13,000 meters per day a 1, below 7,500 a 5.
- Test the result. Change the heaviest weights and see whether the ranking holds.
With material flow at 20 and implementation risk at 20, variant B scores 400 and variant C 380. When two variants are this close in utility, money and risk decide.
The investment
Variant B costs EUR 310,000. Moving and recommissioning 28 machines takes EUR 140,000, utilities EUR 75,000, and the rest goes to floor, stations, planning and contingency.
The benefit per year
The shorter ways save 153 minutes of forklift travel per day, 612 hours per year, EUR 30,600 at EUR 50 per hour. Buffers shrink from 500 to 100 square meters, and EUR 150,000 less stock saves EUR 30,000 of carrying cost at 20 percent. Together that is EUR 60,600 per year.
Against this benefit alone, variant B pays back in 5.1 years.
The real comparison
It is the wrong comparison. Assembly needs its 200 square meters either way. The alternative to variant B is not doing nothing. It is the extension.
| Item | Extension | Variant B | Variant C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Benefit per year in EUR | 0 | 60,600 | 64,250 |
| Time to completion in weeks | 39 | 12 | 16 |
| One-time cost in EUR | 480,000 | 310,000 | 730,000 |
Variant B costs EUR 170,000 less than the extension, is finished in 12 weeks instead of nine months and makes the flow shorter instead of longer. Variant C buys 10 more points and EUR 3,650 more benefit per year for EUR 420,000 of additional investment.
The plant decides for B.
The pattern behind the example
A layout rarely pays by transport alone. It pays by what it makes unnecessary: a building, an external warehouse, stock.