Skip to content
Lean and Green | Part 3 of 10

CO2 per Good Part: One Number, One Method

How to calculate energy and CO2e per good part from bills and output, with Scope 1, 2 and 3 and the choice of emission factors.

A customer sends a questionnaire: what is the CO2e of one valve block, how was it calculated, and what is your reduction target? Many plants need weeks to answer. Some never do.

With twelve months of bills and the output of the same months, the core answer takes an afternoon.

The calculation

The example plant made 600,000 good parts in one year and used 4,200 MWh of electricity and 1,800 MWh of natural gas.

  • Energy per part: 6,000,000 kWh / 600,000 = 10.0 kWh.
  • CO2e from electricity: 4,200,000 kWh × 0.380 kg = 1,596 t.
  • CO2e from gas: 1,800,000 kWh × 0.201 kg = 362 t.
  • CO2e per part: 1,958,000 kg / 600,000 = 3.26 kg.

The factors here are example values for calculation practice. Use the factor from your electricity contract or the official value for your country and reporting year, and write down which one you used.

Scope 1, 2 and 3

Emissions are grouped into three scopes:

  • Scope 1: direct emissions on site, for example gas burned for heating and washing. In the example 0.60 kg per part.
  • Scope 2: purchased electricity, heat and steam. In the example 2.66 kg per part.
  • Scope 3: everything upstream and downstream, from materials and transport to use and end of life.

For most machined parts, Scope 3 is the largest. One valve block contains 1.1 kg of aluminum. With an example factor of 8 kg CO2e per kg, that alone is about 8.8 kg, almost three times the plant share. The factor varies widely with recycled content and origin, so ask your suppliers for their own data.

Location based or market based

For electricity there are two views. The location based figure uses the average factor of the grid. The market based figure uses the factor of the contract you actually buy, for example a green power contract.

Customers increasingly ask which one you report. State the method next to every number and never compare a location based figure with a market based one.

Read the months

Monthly figures tell a story. In the example, January needs 12.9 kWh per part and July 8.0 kWh. Gas for heating explains most of the difference. Compare each month with the same month of the previous year, and divide by good parts so that scrap carries its full energy into the number.

One owner, one method

Put one person in charge of the calculation and of all customer requests. Write the method on one page: data sources, factors, scopes included, what is measured and what is estimated.

When the next questionnaire arrives, the answer comes from the same data the plant uses for steering. That is more credible than any number calculated only for the customer, and it takes two days instead of two months.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.