The classic value stream map shows where time is lost between process steps. It says nothing about energy. Yet the same map, with a few extra boxes, shows exactly where kilowatt hours are lost.
How to draw it
Start with the value stream of one product family, with cycle times and stock between the steps. Then add a data box per step:
- kW while producing,
- kW while waiting between parts or in short stops,
- kW in standby outside production.
Measure with a logger for one week per step, or estimate from the nameplate and the running hours. Mark estimates in a different color. Calculate kWh per part and split it into value-adding and idle.
Add utilities and infrastructure as their own line: lighting, ventilation, heating and the base of the compressed air system. No process step owns them, but every part carries them.
The example
In the valve block plant the energy per part looks like this:
| Step | kWh per part | Idle | Value-adding |
|---|---|---|---|
| CNC machining | 5.2 | 1.6 | 3.6 |
| Washing | 1.6 | 0.6 | 1.0 |
| Leak and function test | 0.6 | 0.2 | 0.4 |
| Sawing, deburring, assembly, packing | 1.1 | 0.3 | 0.8 |
| Infrastructure | 1.5 | ||
| Total | 10.0 | 2.7 | 5.8 |
Machining needs half of all energy, and almost a third of it is consumed while the machine waits. Spindle cooling, coolant pumps and chip conveyors keep running between parts and during short stops.
The idle line
The most useful line on an energy value stream is the idle share. In the example 2.7 of 10.0 kWh per part are used while nothing is produced at that step.
The idle share does not need new technology to fall. It needs a standard for what a machine does when it waits: which pumps switch off after how many minutes, which conveyors stop, when the machine goes into standby. Modern machine controls offer these functions. Often they are simply not used.
Mark three losses
After the map is drawn, mark the three largest losses. In the example they are the idle share of machining, the washer bath heated on weekends and the infrastructure share during nights. They become the first measures.
Connect to time
Energy and time waste often have the same cause. A machine that waits for material wastes time and energy. A batch that is too large fills a heated warehouse. When the time value stream improves, the energy value stream improves with it, and the energy map often gives the extra argument that gets the time improvement approved.
Update the map once a year, or whenever a line changes. The second map is the proof that the first one led to action.