A station that is switched off produces nothing, however many people stand in the area. That decides the order of the whole plan: operating hours first, head count second.
The constraint nobody can hire away
Area A2 has eight stations. In two shifts of 7.5 paid hours over 250 operating days they give 8 x 250 x 15 = 30,000 station hours per year. The program needs 35,000 attendance hours. The gap of 5,000 hours is operating time, not labor. Hiring five people adds nothing, because there is no shift for them to work in.
Station hours can only be created in five ways: a further shift on all stations, a further shift on some stations, more operating days, longer shifts, or more stations. A sixth way lowers the requirement instead: less work content or higher utilization, the only one that also lowers the cost per unit.
Five models on one page
Cost is the station hours at a base rate of EUR 38.00 per attendance hour, with premium factors of 10 percent for the late shift, 25 percent for night and Saturday and 50 percent for Sunday. All of these are freely chosen example values.
| Shift model | Load | People | EUR per hour | Station hours | EUR per year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 Two shifts, 5 days (today) | 117 % | 21 | 39.90 | 30,000 | 1,197,000 |
| 02 Two shifts plus 30 Saturday shifts | 110 % | 22 | 40.33 | 31,800 | 1,282,500 |
| 03 Two shifts plus night shift on 4 stations | 93 % | 26 | 41.42 | 37,500 | 1,553,250 |
| 04 Three shifts, 5 days | 78 % | 31 | 42.43 | 45,000 | 1,909,500 |
| 05 Two shifts plus weekend crew | 88 % | 28 | 42.89 | 39,600 | 1,698,600 |
Load is the 35,000 attendance hours divided by the station hours of the model. Above 100 percent the model does not carry the program. People are the station hours divided by 1,537.5 net attendance hours, times the allowance of 5 percent, rounded up, because every post is staffed for a whole shift whether the program fills it or not.
Reading the table
Models 01 and 02 are out: they cannot deliver the hours. Of the three that remain, model 03 is cheaper by EUR 145,350 than model 05 and by EUR 356,250 than model 04, and it needs five people fewer than three full shifts. The highest cost per hour does not mean the highest cost: model 03 carries 25 percent less idle capacity than model 04. Decide on the total, not on the rate.
Burden belongs in the comparison
Cost alone decides badly here. Count two more numbers per model and put them in the table:
- Night weeks per employee and year. About nine in model 03 with rotation, about thirteen in model 04.
- Weekends worked per employee and year. Zero in models 01, 03 and 04, up to 30 in model 02 and up to 50 in the weekend crew of model 05.
Agree rotation direction and speed with the people who work the pattern. In most teams a pattern that can be read twelve months ahead is worth more than a small premium.
The decision in area A2
The plant chose model 03: two shifts on all eight stations plus a night shift on four of them. The night shift runs the pre-assembly and packing stations, which have the deepest qualification, and fills a buffer that the two day shifts draw from. Twenty-six people, 37,500 station hours, EUR 1,553,250 per year, 93 percent load.
What a comparison does not answer
Working time limits, rest periods, night work rules, weekend permission, premium rates and co-determination are answered by the responsible function at your site and by the agreements that apply there. Put those questions on the agenda before you choose, and treat every rate above as an example value until your own figures replace it.